Me, traumatized? Don’t be silly! So many people out there had it way worse! I’ll be fine. Nothing to see here…move along…
This just about sums up my understanding of trauma until the year 2020. In other words, I was clueless. I remember when I first heard a student talk about something called Complex Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (CPTSD). I remember this because, whereas it was easy for me to trivialize my own trauma (see above), I could not do the same to her.
This student had plateaued with her qigong practice and was asking me for help. Around the same time, another student came to me with a similar problem. In both cases, their health issues simply were not improving, and this totally baffled me.
When students don’t get results with qigong, it’s usually because:
- They’re practicing incorrectly.
- They’re not practicing enough.
- They’ve got a hidden blockage.
Both of these students were practicing correctly and at a sufficient dosage. That left option 3 as the only explanation. I had to find out more, and thus began my journey down the rabbit hole of modern trauma research.
Today, the study of trapped trauma has become a major part of my life and my teachings. Let me give you an idea how significant my research has been:
For the last 17 years, the topic of depression has been a major theme of my teachings. Similarly, I predict that trapped trauma will be a major theme of my teachings for the next 17 years.
I believe that qigong is powerful medicine if we want to heal from trauma. But if we don’t understand trauma and adjust our qigong practice accordingly, then we may plateau, just like my students did. In fact, I myself did something similar.
At the end of this article I’ll give you 13 tips to make your qigong practice more productive when dealing with trapped trauma. Follow these tips and you’ll avoid the mistakes that I made.
What is Trauma?
You’ve probably seen the word “trauma” popping up more often lately. That’s largely because Dr. Besser van der Kolk, M.D., wrote a book called The Body Keeps the Score. This book is over 400 pages long and contains many stories of abuse that are potentially triggering. Doesn’t exactly seem like the recipe for a bestseller, does it?
And yet, this book has been on the NY Times bestseller list for nearly 2 years. As a new nonfiction author who has just done his first lap through the world of publishing, I fully appreciate how incredible this is. The book’s success shows that people are starving for quality information about trauma. I know I was.
Here’s what van der Kolk has to say about trauma:
…trauma is specifically an event that overwhelms the central nervous system, altering the way we process and recall memories. Trauma is not the story of something that happened back then. It’s the current imprint of that pain, horror, and fear living inside people.”
When you think of trauma, think of an overwhelmed nervous system rather than the event itself. Child abuse is an obvious example. The event might be 3 decades in the past and may not even be accessible to conscious memory, and yet the nervous system can still be overwhelmed years later.
Seemingly insignificant events can also be traumatizing if they overwhelm the nervous system. For example, at the age of 3, I wandered off when my babysitter wasn’t looking. I walked about a half mile into a completely foreign suburban neighborhood that we were visiting. Long story short, some adults found me, called the police, and after a ride in the patrol car, I was reunited with my anxious parents.
Shit happens, right? Kids get lost in malls and airports. The question we should be asking, however, is whether or not the event overwhelmed the child’s nervous system. In my case, it did.
If something as significant as child abuse can remain hidden for decades, imagine all the less-obvious traumas that you are probably trivializing. And the traumas may not even be from childhood; a series of smaller traumas in adulthood can also overwhelm the nervous system.
Complex PTSD (CPTSD)
If you’ve read my book or taken any of my classes, then you know about my battles with depression and anxiety. My depression was severe and debilitating. I have journal entries from my teenage years that show clear signs of depression, I was officially diagnosed in my 20s, and if not for qigong, I would likely be dead.
But what if my diagnosis was wrong all along? What if depression and anxiety were just downstream symptoms of an older problem further upstream? What if I was actually dealing with Complex PTSD all along?
According to PsychCentral, symptoms of CPTSD often include the same types of symptoms seen with PTSD, such as:
- recurrent and intrusive thoughts or dreams
- flashbacks
- mental and physical reactions to reminders of the traumatic event
- avoidance of people, places, things, or events that remind you of the trauma
- memory loss
- negative thoughts toward yourself or the world
- self-blame
- bad moods that stick around
- detachment and disinterest
- difficulty showing positive emotion
- irritability
- recklessness
- hypervigilance, or being on “high alert”
- trouble concentrating
- startling easily
- trouble sleeping
If you live with CPTSD, you could also have more severe symptoms of Disturbances of Self-Organization (DSO), like:
- a negative view of yourself
- dissociation, or disconnecting from yourself and your emotions
- emotions that feel “out of control”
- relationship difficulties
- loss of your belief system
- difficulty recognizing reality
For many of you reading this, these symptoms may hit home. I know they did for me. Even before the pandemic, CPTSD was a growing epidemic. Covid has made everything much, much worse.
Holy Shit, I have CPTSD!
In news that will surprise absolutely no one, people are now developing trauma-like symptoms as the pandemic wears on. The article explains that experiencing the world as profoundly unsafe can overwhelm the nervous system and this can lead to CPTSD. And when our nervous system is overwhelmed, it can have long-lasting consequences.
For me, the pandemic triggered a decades-old sense of danger that I could not consciously explain. During this time, I was also doing a lot of zuo chan or sitting meditation in conjunction with my regular qigong practice. The combination of these two things — the feeling of danger from the pandemic plus the practice of sitting meditation — caused repressed memories to surface in my psyche.
Childhood trauma can be trapped in your tissues whether you realize it or not. I certainly didn’t. It wasn’t until late 2020 that I started to make sense of what happened to me.
What Happened to Me
Earlier, I mentioned that I exhibited symptoms of depression back in my teenage years. But my trauma goes back even farther, as I discovered when I went through an intense trauma therapy called Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR). This strange therapy, which is half neuroscience and half magic, helped me to access memories of childhood trauma that I had repressed for decades.
I’m not yet ready to talk openly about this trauma. For now, I’ll just mention that it involved a teacher who was also a family friend. This is relevant to our discussion about trauma, as you’ll see in a moment.
I’ve written at length about how I left my qigong teacher of 17 years over a sexual abuse scandal perpetrated by one of his certified instructors. I even talked about the death threats I received after blowing the whistle on the scandal. But what I’ve never mentioned — because I wasn’t yet aware of it — was how the scandal triggered my own childhood trauma. To leave your teacher of 17 years, who had formerly been your hero, and then to be attacked and libeled by him afterward — this might traumatize anyone. In my case, it was even worse because it triggered something from my childhood, something that also involved a male teacher and betrayal and abuse.
Qigong managed my trauma quite well for decades. In fact, it worked so well that I didn’t even know I was dealing with childhood trauma. Even after I left my teacher, I was okay for a few years. During that time, I successfully navigated the stress of a divorce, the closing of my qigong studio, the death of my grandmother, and a back injury. Yay for qigong!
Then the pandemic hit, and it turned out to be the straw that broke my nervous system’s back.
Getting Help
One day, as I was sitting in meditation, I had a sudden “knowing”. I find it impossible to describe the experience, but I said these words aloud to myself afterward: “We’re going to have to look at it someday.”
I realized that I needed help. I knew a little about trauma by this point in time, so I started looking for trauma-informed therapists. I tried several different therapies and therapists with varying degrees of success. Eventually, I was “diagnosed” with CPTSD.
I put that word in quotation marks because, unfortunately, CPTSD is still not an official diagnosis in the United States. In other words, mental health professionals still have no choice but to diagnose me with depression and/or anxiety because CPTSD is not yet an option. Nevertheless, one of my therapists made it clear that I had all the symptoms and signs of CPTSD.
In his book, Dr. van der Kolk talks about how he and his colleagues advocated for the inclusion of something called Developmental Trauma Disorder (DTD) in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-V) back in 2011. The American Psychiatric Association (APA) rejected his request, citing “no known evidence” as their reason. But van der Kok had provided considerable evidence even as far back as 2011. Today, Dr. van der Kolk and his colleagues have amassed a large body of evidence that, unfortunately, still has not been accepted by the APA.
However, the International Classification of Diseases, version 11 (ICD-11) published in 2018 does recognize CPTSD as a mental health disorder. Ahem, so I guess there’s evidence after all!
What’s in a Diagnosis?
Mental health diagnoses are tricky and ever-changing. For example, Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) wasn’t officially added to the DSM until 1980. But the problem had existed long before.
Everyone has heard the term “shell shocked”. This term was first adopted after WW1. Originally, doctors thought that there had been some damage to the brain that caused soldiers to experience insomnia, amnesia, headaches, dizziness, tremors, and noise hypersensitivity. Some of these poor men were branded as weak and even executed for military cowardice.
Today, we know that they were not cowards, nor were their brains damaged. Or rather, their brains were damaged, but not by the force of the artillery. Rather, the central nervous system, which includes the brain, was damaged by the experience of the war.
DTD and CPTSD are not yet official diagnoses in the U.S., but they will be one day, just like PTSD. The American Psychiatric Association can only resist for so long. I predict that the success of Dr. van der Kolk’s book will force them to take another look at trauma and include new diagnoses in the next edition of the DSM.
At that point, will my decades-old diagnosis shift from Major Depressive Disorder (MDD) to something like CPTSD or DTD? Who knows. In the end, a diagnosis is only a label. What really matters is what we do to heal.
What Can We Do to Heal?
I decided to tell a bit of my trauma story in this post for one main reason: Because I hope it will help some of you to acknowledge your own trauma.
Don’t trivialize your trauma the way I did. In fact, trivializing trauma is a symptom of trauma! So if your first reaction is to dismiss what happened to you, then it probably means you need to take a closer look at it.
With the tips and resources below, you will be well prepared to heal your own trauma. Be warned, however, that you might feel resistance when digging in to your trauma. Believe me, I get it! But if you’re ready to do the work, then the resources below will help!
Books to Read:
Here are a few books that I think are worth reading. If you suspect that you’re dealing with trapped trauma, or if you know someone who might be dealing with it, then knowledge is power. These books will give you a crash course into the topic of trapped trauma.
- The Body Keeps the Score: Brain, Mind, and Body in the Healing of Trauma by Bessel van der Kolk M.D.
- Waking the Tiger: Healing Trauma by Peter A. Levine
- Trauma: The Invisible Epidemic: How Trauma Works and How We Can Heal From It by Paul Conti M.D.
- What Happened to You?: Conversations on Trauma, Resilience, and Healing by Oprah Winfrey and Bruce D. Perry, M.D., Ph.D
- Radical Acceptance: Awakening the Love That Heals Fear and Shame by Tara Brach
What I find fascinating is that virtually all of the books I’ve read on trauma mention qigong as a therapy. They don’t just mention tai chi, meditation, or yoga – but qigong specifically. This is great news for us!
Therapies to Explore:
Here are some of the therapies that I have personally tried. Of these, I found that Internal Family Systems worked the best for me. Your experience might be different. If you choose to try EMDR, make sure to do it with a skilled professional. Whatever you do, DO NOT try to do it on your own. You’ve been warned!
- Internal Family Systems Therapy
- Somatic Experiencing
- EMDR
- Yoga
- Qigong (see below)
If You’re in Crisis Right Now
If you know my story, then you know that I almost killed myself in my 20s. Back then, I had no clue about suicide prevention. I was lucky to survive.
The US National Suicide Prevention Lifeline saves lives. They are amazingly helpful if you need to talk. Call this number immediately: (800) 273-8255.
If you don’t feel like calling, then click here and look for the LIVE CHAT button. It’s available 24 hours per day, 7 days per week, in both English and Spanish.
Or if you’re outside of the US, then please click here for a list of international hotlines.
13 Tips for Healing Trauma with Qigong:
Qigong heals trauma, but there are things we can do to make it more efficient. This is an area that I am actively studying, but below are my findings so far. I will remind you that I am not a licensed psychologist nor a psychiatrist. However, I am an expert in qigong.
If you are new to qigong, or new to my style of qigong, then some of these tips may not make sense. That’s okay. There’s enough here for you to play with no matter what.
Here are my tips, in no particular order:
Tip #1: Try the Flowing Zen 5-Phase Routine, especially if you’ve been unsuccessful in treating your trapped trauma with qigong. You can learn it in my book. This routine is a game-changer for many people, even if they’ve been doing qigong for decades. The entire routine only takes 10-15 minutes and it is an easy way to implement the most important qigong secrets into your daily practice.
Tip #2: Look around in all directions (up and down too) immediately before your qigong session. Move the head and eyes slowly, as if scanning for danger. You are gently telling your nervous system that you are safe and that there are no predators nearby. This also works for yoga, tai chi, and sitting meditation.
Tip #3: Use the qigong exercise called Shaking the Tree to help you relax before your session. If you don’t know this exercise, then you can learn it for free here. This exercise anchors the Monkey Mind into a physical movement and gives it a way to release stored tension. Try the exercise by itself for 2 minutes and you’ll feel the difference. Then incorporate the same technique into the beginning of your qigong session.
Tip #4: Use pandiculation. When you wake up in the morning or after a good nap and then stretch randomly and yawn – that’s pandiculation. Try using artificial pandiculation before a qigong session. Just pretend you’re waking up from the world’s best summer nap and then stretch and move spontaneously for 10-15 seconds.
Tip #5: Try to actively yawn. This goes hand-in-hand with pandiculation, and they complement each other. You can stimulate a yawn by opening your mouth as wide as you can and then trying to say the letter “R” 3-4 times. Keep your mouth wide open as you do this. In a few seconds, you should feel the urge to yawn. Encourage that yawn! This will stimulate your parasympathetic nervous system (rest and restore), which will calm you down before even doing any qigong!
Tip #6: Keep the eyes open or half-open for most of your qigong session. Closing the eyes may tense up the nervous system because it can make you feel vulnerable. If you are practicing in a public place like a park, then this is even more important.
Tip #7: Choose qigong exercises with vocalizations, like Punching with Wide Eyes, One Finger Zen, or the 18 Arhats. If you don’t know any of these, then you can add a gentle sighing sound (e.g. “ahhhhh) to any of the techniques that you know. Use this vocalization on half or all of the exhalations. Or you can use techniques from other schools of qigong that have vocalizations.
Tip #8: Use Five Animal Play 1-2 times per week with full privacy. If you don’t know Five Animal Play yet, just use Flowing Breeze Swaying Willow, but try to encourage spontaneous vocalizations. Privacy is key here. If you inhibit yourself for fear of being heard by your spouse or your neighbors, it won’t work as well.
Tip #9: Check your jaw tension throughout your session. Get in the habit of releasing that tension whenever it creeps back in (which it will). Wiggle your jaw in all directions, and also loosen your tongue. Doing this will relax your vagus nerve, which in turn will help to unwind your nervous system.
Tip #10: Close at the mingmen vital point instead of dantian at the end of the session. Or you can consolidate at dantian first, then finish with mingmen. If you don’t know how to do this, then use Guideline #3 here.
Tip #11: Before and/or during your session, talk gently to yourself as if talking to a child. Say something like, “Don’t worry kiddo, you are safe now,” or “It’s going to be okay.” Choose words that you yourself might use to console a child who just went through a traumatic experience. Or if you can’t imagine a child, then imagine how you would talk to an animal that was recently frightened. You don’t need to speak out loud, but you certainly can.
Tip #12: Use One Finger Zen before and after a session, or on its own. You can learn how to do this here. The idea is to bring your awareness into your body and, if you have some qigong skill, into your energy flow. Try to feel the qi in your index finger as you walk around before and after your session.
Tip #13: Start with the Closing Sequence and focus on the sensations of the self-massage. Normally, we close our session like this, but we can also use it as an opening sequence. The somatic nature of the self-massage helps to bring us out of our heads and into our bodies. After doing the Closing Sequence, begin the 5-Phase Routine as normal (ending with the Closing Sequence again in Phase 5).
…
Try some of these tips and let me know how it goes. Did you find one of them particularly helpful? Your feedback will help me to further develop my theories about qigong and trauma.
I’ve touched on many important trauma-related subjects in this post. I mean, each of the subheadings could be a separate blog post on its own! Rest assured that this is just the beginning of our trauma conversation. Expect more blog posts diving deeper into the topic of trauma and qigong.
And please remember that I am not a doctor or a therapist. This article is for informational purposes only, and nothing is meant to be used as professional or medical advice. Be well and take care of yourself! From the heart, Sifu Anthony
Thank you for this post Sifu Anthony. I’ve been doing therapy on and off for anxiety since 2017. I’ve recently heard about Internal Family Systems and tried EMDR on my own a few times grom watching Youtube videos but I stopped. I recently picked up my Qigong practice again and was wondering if Qigong can heal deep rooted trauma and negative self beliefs. This post helps alot. And thank you for your transparency. It motivates me to practice even more.
I’m glad you stopped doing EMDR on your own. It’s too risky.
To answer your question, yes, I believe that qigong can heal deep-rooted trauma. If you practice loving kindness, that will also help with the negative self-talk!
Thanks a lot for the response. I struggle with loving kindness but will persist practicing.
Yes, self-compassion is incredibly difficult. Maybe this article will help: https://flowingzen.com/21862/too-many-mind/
Thank you.
Great, great, great Amazing post! Thank you so much. This was a real learning experience for me and I will revisit often. I’m excited to start a Qigong session right now and try a couple of your tips.
Tip from my experience: I’ve been doing Flowing Zen Qigong for over 3 years now. I learned Shaking the Tree (#3 in the post) early on, then kind of set it aside for a while, and now it has become commonplace in my daily life. I do it while standing at my computer waiting on a process to finish, sitting in my car at a traffic light, waiting on my food to heat up, or when I’m in a doctor’s office alone waiting on the doctor to come in etc etc… There are many opportunities to practice this exercise throughout the day and it is very relaxing and refreshing. Just thought I’d throw that tip in there in case it’s of use to other readers. Note that I do not do it while standing in line in public, but I do practice the the Brocade “Shaking the Back” in public quite often.
Terrific! Thanks for that. So basically, you’re saying use Shaking Tree as the 2-minute drill throughout the day?
Yes, pretty much the 2 minute drill throughout the day whenever I have time waiting around, whether it be 1 minute or 5. I also make sure to get in the 5 phase routine one to two times per day. Thank you for the life changing teachings.
Got it. You’re getting a really good dosage of qigong, so I’m not surprised it’s helping!
This blog post is so beautiful…. this has been my passion for so many decades. and Sifu Anthony being so open and honest, and an “open book” so to speak, indeed can be very healing to many. I have a similar history, with a minister, ( my dads best friend,) when i was a young girl. I am not ashamed of this, but i do not talk about it in my field too often. I feel there is no shame in my journey, and Sifu, i was beyond proud when i read at the end of your book what you did to expose corruptness, yes you are a stanger……..but damn I was proud of you for sticking up for integrity, and I know without a shadow of a doubt I am to learn my next phase of my journey from You. what ever it takes, whatever it cost 🙂 . finding Flowing Zen is helping me beyond measure in just 17 days being a Nurse in mental illness. Thank you, thank you.
Haha, I’m not sure how I feel about being such an open book, but I promised transparency years ago when I left my teacher and here we ware.
Thank you for the kind words and the support. I’m so glad that qigong is helping you so much!
Wonderful, informative, awakening post. Thank you so much for letting us know more of your personal exploration.
Thank you! Big hug from Jacksonville!
Haven’t been ready to restart a TC or QC practice in 3 years but this post made me feel less afraid. Restarting, at least in TC, has felt like a self-betrayal. I could never work with any teacher/healer that is not trauma-informed again, let alone continue using his training.
To feel closer to a personal wish– it is actual progress, of which I’m proud to see. Thank you Anthony for your willingness to meet your students– and yourself– where you are. Please keep talking about why we’re feeling stuck. It makes a difference.
I hope that you can find your way back to feeling safe with qigong. I think that some of the tips above will really help you. If you learned some good qigong in the past, you can safely combine it with the 5-Phase Routine and these tips. You don’t need to throw out what you’ve learned. On the other hand, if it feels safer to learn new techniques, then do that instead.
Sifu, I’m so glad you’re going deeper into trauma in your blogposts, and indeed sorting out a Trauma-Informed Qigong (now, that would be a good short class/workshop!). I recently realized the depth of trauma I encountered as a child and teen and the profound nature of its ongoing effect in my life, and so much of what you wrote here resonates with me. I’ll be putting your recommendations to the test in my own practice in the next several months and report back as to progress. 🙂 (The migraines are almost totally gone, btw, and of course, they were trauma related.) Thank you so much for your research and reflections, and for sharing them with us.
Actively healing,
Sare
Thank you!
I think that Trauma-Informed Qigong will be a class at the very least, or possibly a module that complements my other programs.
I’m glad to hear that the migraines are going away. That’s huge! Keep up the amazing work.
Good list. As a licensed therapist, I work with trauma patients daily (CPTSD / PTSD / etc.). The most overlooked factor therapists make is the physical connection, largely because most lack training in this area. Before healing and changing perspectives about the trauma(s), the body needs to be at its best. This means diet, water, sleep, movement, and breathing. 4-square breathing, dropping the jaw, and qigong makes a huge difference in my patients who practice it daily. If the body is always tense, the brain has difficulty letting go and moving forward.
Exactly. If the body is tense, then so is the nervous system. And it’s bi-directional too. A tense CNS means a tense body. Both need to be relaxed systematically.
What a beautiful article Sifu. Your trauma-informed approach to qigong is going to help so many people moving forward. Qigong is a potent form of somatic healing with correlations to Reichian breathing and Bioenergetics. Keep up the great work. You are going to be at the forefront of this.
Thank you, sir! I appreciate your perspective and your encouragement!
One can read books and web sites for ever, it seems and you can nod your head and mutter, ‘yep, that could be me’. Then something come along that hits you in the chest like battering ram. And that something was: ‘For example, at the age of 3, I wandered off when my babysitter wasn’t looking’.
Sifu, meet the serial wanderer of Lancaster, north west England circa 1948 (or there abouts) What was going on in my family life back then I really have no idea, but I was I was a complete loner and renown for wandering off and getting lost in the city. Eventually I would be spotted and taken to the police station where they all knew me and my mother summonsed (yet again) to come and take me home.
I only have vague recollections of these wanderings, except for one of them, which is still clear in my mind over 70 years later. I decided one day to go for a paddle in the local canal! I couldn’t swim of course and I got stuck in the mud and if it hadn’t been for a labourer walking along the tow path and spotting me, I would have drowned. And amazingly and this really sticks in my mind, I didn’t even have the courage to cry out for help!
Now if that didn’t leave me with a good dose of CPTSD I can’t imagine what would and certainly, throughout my life some of the symptoms that you list have been very much part of my life.
I was lucky. I discovered and began to practice the 5 phase routine around 10 years ago and have practiced it almost daily ever since and has indeed been of great help. Your book has been very helpful and encouraging as well (it’s on its second reading just now)
I will put in the enhancements that you suggest in this blog into my routine, I started with ‘shaking the tree’ this morning. Hopefully it will shake off my past as well!
Thank you for sharing your experiences with us Sifu and I shall be eagerly awaiting your future blogs.
I’m not a therapist, but the event you describe being stuck in the mud and being unable to cry for help — that sounds traumatizing to me. It’s easy to dismiss things like this, but if you remember it so vividly, and if you couldn’t even scream, then it’s likely you got stuck in what we call the “freeze” state, which means that the dorsal branch of the vagus nerve probably shut down.
I’m thrilled to hear that you’ve been doing the 5-Phase Routine for so long. I’m very curious how these tips help you. Keep us posted please!
Hello Sifu Anthony, this is a great post.
I have a suggestion for Tip 14: go slowly but steadily / avoid overdoing it. I somewhat fell into the trap thinking that “more is better” and my meditation teachers were always telling me to take it easy, go for walks in nature, do grounding activities, chat with friends etc. Beacuse the practice was a bit destabilizing and a lot of ‘weird stuff’ happened. (However this was in the context of sitting meditation where a lot of stuff came up, going through the way of qi gong may be different.)
This is a page with resources on health and safety from a meditation focused reddit that may have some things you didn’t come across yet: https://www.reddit.com/r/streamentry/wiki/health-and-balance
That’s a good tip, but it’s something I already teach. “More is better” is definitely not my approach to qigong. We focus on high-quality sessions rather than quantity.
I know! Yes you’re right, I just realized that you quite explicitly state the 5PR takes 15 minutes, and to do that twice a day maybe. But I still thought to suggest to add it to the tips because there are always people like me who ignore things and go full steam ahead 🙂
Anyway thank you for writing this post, I think it’s great that there’s so much attention now to the role the body plays in trauma.
Thank you for an informative post!
As a traumatherapist and qigong practitioner, I would say that qigong and yoga have strengths when it comes to trauma treatment in that they are efficient in releasing that which can be accessed, and they do a very good job with balancing us.
Their main weakness, in my opinion, is that they for most part are not constructed to access things that are locked in by the automatic defence reactions (freeze and so on).
Thanks for the comment, Tomas. Can you please say more about qigong not being constructed to access things locked by automatic defense reactions?
Sorry for replying to an old comment, but this is something I´m also very interested in. Perhaps Tomas means something like this. Say someone has been extremely frightened by loud noises in a combat situation. After the traumatizing event, this person might startle at everyday noises in his daily life even though the situation is safe.
For this mechanism, I would like to quote a yoga site which says ¨[The] Autonomic system is at work when we react unaware, in an unusual manner whenever faced with an emergency, because the autonomic nervous system has access to the sub conscious mind from where it retrieves the information for handling the emergency at hand without the knowledge of the conscious mind.¨
Perhaps Tomas believes Qigong cannot as it were access that kind of information (about how the nervous system reacts to threats), nor overwrite/´unlearn´ those reflexes.
My TCM practitioner, however, has said that it might be possible to rewire your brain if you are in a parasympathetic state (through the vagus nerve) for an extended period of time and then gradually expose yourself to the stimuli again.
I´m extremely curious what your thoughts are on this Sifu, and also thanks for your great book, it has motivated me to practice Qigong twice daily=)
Thank you for this important post. I have cptsd from many years of child abuse and undiagnosed health issues/”nuerodivergences”, and have been doing the 201 program this past year. Until about 3 weeks ago, although I was learning new exercises at a slow pace, I was diligently doing the 5-phase routine daily. I could feel it slowly shifting energy, and it’s improved my ease of motion. It’s also improved my body awareness so that I was able to help my PT figure out the root cause behind a 15-year-old set of chronic problems, which was particularly cool.
Something I struggle with: my nervous system is in a long phase of saying No to many many things that would theoretically be beneficial to do. I’ve become aware that this is because for the first 24ish years of my life, most demands placed on me were traumatizing me and making me sicker (though in some areas, it wasn’t anyone’s fault– teachers didn’t know I was not well enough to be held to the same standards, drs didn’t know how to dx me, etc). I wasn’t allowed to say No in some settings, and didn’t understand that I could in others, so Id continue functioning as I was Supposed To literally until I passed out. Now my nervous system rebels against most directions/advice/experts, and elements of my routine continually get contaminated by a sense of toxic obligation.
Current issue: I stopped doing the 5-phase routine qigong daily for 5 days because I was in bed with covid. Now, my brain hears my intention to start again as a “Should,” and is rebelling. Do you have any advice? So far I have been looking for the smallest amount it can feel nonthreatened by and trying that… which has meant amounts like, “thinking about it for 30 seconds” or “none” or “standing in the center of the room sort of wiggling.” I think this part of myself is testing my patience because it doesn’t believe I’m serious about only doing what my nervous system is on board with :/
Try changing the thought of “I should practice” to “I get to practice”. And start with 2 minutes a day rather than trying to do the full routine. See if that works!
Thank you for this Sifu. As someone who is both a survivor of trauma myself, a trauma psychotherapist, and the founder of a charity working with trauma survivors; I know how vital it is to find a body-mind practice to help clear the blockages caused by trauma – in particular by early developmental trauma.
Even knowing what I know, It has taken me a long time to recognise that my own chronic health conditions are in large part a manifestation of these blockages, as is my difficulty in sticking with a practice for long enough to make a real difference.
I have long been of the opinion that we need to adapt mindfulness practices to work safely with people with CPTSD, and I am excited to see you doing the same with Qigong for survivors of trauma. ‘Coincidentally’ I have just started to try to reset and restart some Qigong practice using the 2 minute Emergency Motivation routine, to try to clear some of the blocks I am experiencing, so I will be incorporating some or all off these highly useful adaptations to the method.
Thank you once again
Giles
Thank you for this article Sifu Anthony, and thank you for the amazing vulnerability and authenticity you show in it.
I am a survivor of trauma, and a trauma psychotherapist, and the founder of a charity working with survivors of trauma. I’ve known for a while now that many of my own physical health problems are related to the blockages caused by unresolved trauma. I have also suspected that my struggles to establish and maintain healthy habits such as Qigong, are also related to this trapped trauma. Despite all the therapy that has helped to resolve most of the psychological issues; when it comes to body/mind oriented treatments at some point – whether it’s a week, a month or even 100 days, everything collapses, seemingly overnight.
I’ve asked myself why this is, and I think it may be related to something I see in my therapy work over and over again. It took me a while to realise that many traditional mindfulness practices, whilst helpful for many people, are actually counter-productive for those with CPTSD. Either the practices increase anxiety to the point that they become impossible, or if the person pushes through, their resilience and will to work with it erodes over time. My colleagues and I discovered that making some small but significant adjustments to the practices can prove highly beneficial.
What you are doing here with Qigong, is really exciting. It seems as if you are making the same types of adjustments that are going to help CPTSD sufferers including myself. I am really looking forward to finding out more, and being able to engage with a Qigong that works for survivors.
Thank you once again
Giles
Thank you for the comment, Giles. When you say that “everything collapses seemingly overnight,” are you referring to mind-body practices? Can you tell me more?
Yes I mean the mind-body practices, so Qigong or sitting meditation. It is as if when I stumble and miss a day, certainly if I miss more than one day, no matter that I may have been practicing for 21 days or 100 days, it all goes, and it can take months to pick myself back up and start practicing again.
At the moment I’m trying to get back on track with your 2 minute emergency willpower routine. I figure for survivors of trauma, taking bite sized pieces may well work better, because we can do 2 minutes even on the days when life feels overwhelming.
Great article Sifu!
The closing at Mingmen instead of Dantian part was the most helpful for me,and I have some questions about that:
1.I felt whenever I close at the Dantian that alot of emotions surface,like a battering ram that hits my body and stresses me out,I am curious as to how closing at the Dantian causes this reaction.
Is it because the Dantian stores the trauma as trapped energy inside of it?
Does closing at the Dantian mean that the rush of fresh energy causes that very same traumatic energy to surge out in the body’s attempt to be rid of the trauma held in the Dantian?
Or is it something completey different?
2.Does closing at the Mingmen helps the Dantian to more gently purify/cleanse/whatever the trauma locked inside of it?
If so,how does it do that?
If not,what does it do when I close there?
I think dantian can be a trigger for some people. Trauma is often stored in the hips, and dantian is pretty close. But it doesn’t matter why you’re getting triggered. If Mingmen feels better, then use that!
Closing at Mingmen doesn’t purify/cleanse more. It’s just an alternative. But it also nourishes the Kidney Meridian, which in turn helps with fear-based triggers and anxiety.
Aha,trauma often being stored at the hips would explain why I also have a lot of difficulty with Tai Chi Chuan.
I recall its heavily based on dantian/hip area movement and work
whenever I try to practice it,I have to stop practicing rather quickly,otherwise it becomes overwhelming for me.
I’ll definitely keep closing at Mingmen for the foreseeable future untill things calm down in the hip area.
Thanks for the info Anthony!
Yet another treasure from you Sifu Anthony! so glad I found your Book. I`m 3 quarters of the way through listening to it on Audible. Think I will have to buy a paper copy.
Sorry I missed this, Dean. I’m glad this article was helpful!
Thank you for this article. I’m glad you had mentioned using shaking the tree at the start of a practice because I had wondered if that would help me relax more. I’ve experienced so much trauma in my life and definitely minimized it. I’ve been only practicing once a day (first thing in the morning) with random 2 minute drills and had thought about writing to you about how often to practice. I tend to “go go go” all day every day. I will also try the eye movements in the beginning of practice as well.